Which is better for learning violin: Western classical or Carnatic? - Quora. Both the Western and Carnatic style of teaching Violin will help you master the instrument, but as a student of music, you should also master the subject called music and not just the instrument.

Is Carnatic violin different from western violin?

The main difference is in the way Indian violinists play their instruments, rather than the instrument itself. ... On the other hand, Carnatic violinists who are based in the south of the country generally maintain a single tempo, much like violinists from Europe.

Is Carnatic violin difficult?

according to me, learning carnatic music is quite difficult. ... Dan, the classical music form comes in both Indian and western music. As you have said you have no formal training in any kind of music.

Should I learn Carnatic music?

Alongside the sound energy of Nada Yoga and its vibrations, Carnatic Music evokes positive physical and spiritual influences, relieving you of all stress. Carnatic music in its instrumental form comes with many advantages for kids, who can refine their hand-eye synchronizations and motor skills.

Can Carnatic singer sing western music?

Yes you can. But it will be better to learn the western music first and then go in for the Indian music. That way you will understand the Indian melodic patterns (ragas) easily and not get confused between a Raga and a Scale. absolutely!

Difference between Carnatic and Western Violin | Which one is best ? | Tamil | Saravana Violinist

36 related questions found

What is the difference between Carnatic and western music?

Indian classical music's magic is primarily experienced with different melodies constructed within the framework of the ragas, while Western classical music's magic lies to a great extent in polyphonic composition, where counterpoint, harmony, and the texture created using multiple voices is critical.

Is Carnatic music unified?

directed to a Hindu god, which is why it is called “temple music” • unlike Hindustani music, Carnatic music is unified where schools are based on the same ragas, the same solo instruments (veena, flute, violin) and the same rhythm instrument (mridangam and ghatam) • music pieces are mainly set for the voice and with ...

How long will it take to learn Carnatic music?

If you start learning Vocal or Instrumental Carnatic Music from Basics....by regular learning and constant practice, you can complete the learning of Basics in 6 months for sure....But continued learning and regular practice IS A MUST. Totally based on your effort and Interest at least 6 months for basics.

Which raga should you learn in Carnatic music?

Some of the major ragas are Mohanam, Sankarabharanam, Aarabhi, Hindolam, Kamas, etc. The major talas are Rupakam, Aadi, Triputa, Dhruva, jhampa, matya. All the Ragas are based on Swaras. You will be able to find seven basic swaras in Indian Classical music.

What is the benefit of learning Carnatic music?

Learning Carnatic Vocal music helps to develop vocal cords in kids and also enhances motor skills in a better way. It helps in correct pronunciation and quality of speech as well. It helps to develop a mesmerizing voice.

Which is better Hindustani vs Carnatic?

Basic Difference: In this respect, Carnatic music fares much better than Hindustani music. For there is between them a basic difference in their approach to raga, sahitya and inspiration. ... On the other hand, Hindustani classical music is a wide open prairie, a kind of Apache land without a sheriff.

Why is violin used in Carnatic music?

The instrument was soon found to be ideal for playing classical Indian music because it lends itself well to its melodic subtleties. Today, it is rare to find a performance of Carnatic music without the violin. Breaking with European tradition, Indian violinists sit cross-legged and hold their instrument vertically.

Is violin used in Indian music?

The violin used in Indian classical music is similar to the one used in Western classical traditions. ... The violin is also extensively used as a solo instrument in both Carnatic and Hindustani styles. It is accompanied by the mridangam, tabla, and allied percussion instruments like the ghatam.

What is a Carnatic violin?

Indian Violin is one of the most exotic and mysterious of sounds. A simple four-stringed instrument played with a bow, its bright, dynamic tone and the infinite variety possible on its fretless fingerboard makes it suitable for almost any kind of music.

Is Indian violin different?

Western classical and Indian classical violin are very, very different styles. The main similarity is that they use the same instrument, so if you learned one style, you would have a head start learning the other.

What are the notes on violin?

The open strings on a violin are tuned to the following pitches, from lowest to highest: G, D, A, E. (Each string sounds a perfect fifth above the one below it.) The first stop on the fingerboard will produce a note that is one whole tone higher than the open string. These notes are A, E, B, and F#.

Which raga should I learn first?

Yaman is a sampurna (consists of 7 notes) raga from the Hindustani music tradition. It is one of the first ragas a Hindustani classical student learns and is considered to be one of the most fundamental ragas in the tradition.

How long does it take to learn Carnatic violin?

So, exactly how long does it take to learn violin? Well, the answer is entirely up to you. With a continuous and steady training schedule, you can make a lot of progress toward your goals in three to five years.

Can I learn Carnatic music on my own?

Shankar Mahadevan Academy provides the unique opportunity for students everywhere to learn Carnatic Vocal music from the convenience of their own home through a highly structured curriculum, a clear path for progression, and certifications for completion.

What is the best age to learn singing?

Children are generally ready for this type of instruction between ages 7 and 9. The human voice continues to mature throughout life, however, so students of any age can benefit from singing lessons. Typically children are ready to start singing between the ages of 7 and 9.

Can I learn singing at the age of 35?

Some of us are born to sing. And if you haven't given it a try yet, you probably think you're too old to start, right? You must be wondering, “can I learn singing at the age of 30?” Well, with hard work and dedication, anyone can learn to sing, no matter the age.

How many notes are there in Carnatic music?

There are 7 musical notes in Carnatic Music, called the Sapta (seven) Swaras (musical notes).

What is kriti in Carnatic music?

Kriti (Sanskrit: कृति, kṛti) is a format of musical composition typical to Carnatic music. Kritis form the mental backbone of any typical Carnatic music concert and is the longer format of Carnatic song. "Kriti" also means Creation.